My rating: 3 of 5 stars
I used my "define words by context" skills quite a bit in this book;
"It was the stickman's job to take the pogue once Teddy had snaffled it, thus leaving Teddy clean..."
"She's a judy. Clean Willy's doll. Pinches laundry, doesn't she? Aye, she does a bit of snow."
"Every night. It's the reeb that does it. Reeb gives a man a powerful urge."
"That's the lay? You popped me out of Newgate for this? This is no shakes, to knock over a deadlurk."
Finally, on page 179, Crichton admits to the cryptic nature of the slang;
"'Dressed proper, with good manner, but speaks a wave lag from Liverpool, and he can voker a romeny." Harrenby glanced at Sharp, in the corner. From time to time, even Harranby needed some help in translation."
The word "cockchafer" was used multiple times before it was defined at the end of the book as a treadmill used to punish prisoners.
This is historical fiction. But one would make a mistake if one actually tried to learn history from this historical fiction. Crichton is an unreliable historian. Though he mentions well-known things from history, like the Crystal Palace from the 1851 Great Exhibition, he also fully invents some things, like the story of George Bateson.
Google George Bateson. There are several articles citing as fact that he invented a system to prevent people from being buried alive. But, in fact, this "fact" originated in this book. Crichton made it up and, through a series of erroneous citations, Crichton's fiction has been elevated by some to fact.
I took it as fact. Then I thought to myself, "Huh. I wonder if 'bats in the belfry' comes from Bateson and his belfry?" It doesn't, of course. George's name and the name of his fictional device is a joke, designed to make the reader think of the phrase, not the other way around.
The Bateson story doesn't happen until 3/4ths of the way through the book. Makes me wonder how many other asides I took on faith as accurate Victorian history when they were really just fanciful inventions of Crichton's imagination. Is a cockchafter even real?
Just another reminder to read, research, and check your facts with reliable sources before you claim something as real. A good lesson to learn, again, in this age of "fake news."
View all my reviews